by Lost_Sage » October 7th, 2008, 2:37 pm
Well, glad to hear the debate's so lively ... I'd sure like to hear from some new folks, though. And where did our Cali and Arizona peeps go?
Anyhoo ...
I really do view Beach as the SEC of kickball. I had roughly five tiers (by letter grade, A-F) of division and tourney strength of schedule. Beach is the only division I assigned an A in strength of schedule. I think the talent level is very deep (even deeper than DC Monument in its heyday when GCAS, Trojan, Brew Group, Balls Deep, Playground Menaces, Play With Me, and New Kicks on the Block were all capable of beating each other). I would still love to go during one of the Beach nights in the winter to see division play first hand. I think VA Shore and DC Liberty/Memorial are a close second.
I'm reminding folks again -- the fall poll will look very different because it will reflect everything we've been talking about as far as roster moves, changes, etc. Many teams are sitting out the fall. Many teams are just playing on ensemble casts (either to decompress or to tune up for next year's tourney scene).
I've always tried to use caution as far as how to treat teams that stay home at tourney time. For the longest time, it was just 1 or 2 big tourneys a year. We all know the time and expense involved in going to one of these things, let alone multiple ones. (Especially us in New York.) But with a more robust tourney schedule in place, and with those regions that can't open it up nationally still doing the smart thing and hosting tourneys for local talent (re: NorCal/SoCal), it will not be long before a team that is absent from the tourney scene, no matter how good it purports to be, will find itself on the outside of a poll looking in. And it is hard
not to reward those teams that don't have a Beach or a Shore or a Memorial division at home and do have to go on the road and find more competition.
CA: Gold Rush (S05/F05), Golden Gate (S05/F05), Yerba Buena (F05-06-07/S06-07)
NY: Big Apple (S06), Central (S10), Freedom (S06-07-08-09-10/U09-10), Gotham (S08/U08), Liberty (S07-08-09), L.I. (S05), Recess (F08), River (U10), Star (F05-06-07-08-09/U10), Victory (U10)
BKKB 06, 08, 09, 10